Bringing home a baby rabbit is exciting, and one of the first things you will buy is hay. It is the most important part of their diet, making up about 80% of what they eat. If you are wondering whether the hay you grab at PetSmart is safe for your new little friend, the short answer is yes, it usually is. But not all hay is created equal, and a few simple checks can make a big difference in your baby rabbit’s health. Let’s walk through what you need to know so you can shop with confidence.

What Kind of Hay Should a Baby Rabbit Eat?

For baby rabbits under seven months old, the best hay is alfalfa hay. It is higher in calcium and protein, which supports their rapid growth and bone development. PetSmart typically carries Oxbow Animal Health hay, which is a reputable brand. Look for the Oxbow Alfalfa Hay or the Oxbow Baby Rabbit Starter Kit which includes alfalfa hay. Avoid giving adult rabbits’ Timothy hay to a baby, as it does not have enough nutrients for their growing bodies. If you are unsure which hay to pick, ask a store associate or check the label for the age recommendation.

How to Check PetSmart Hay for Safety and Freshness

Even though PetSmart sources hay from trusted suppliers, you should still inspect the bag before buying. Here are three quick checks:

  • Look for green color: Fresh hay should be greenish, not brown or yellow. Brown hay is old and has lost most of its nutrients.
  • Smell it: Good hay smells sweet and grassy. If it smells musty, dusty, or sour, do not buy it.
  • Check for mold or dust: Hold the bag up to the light or open the resealable top if possible. You should not see white or gray powder (mold) or excessive dust.

PetSmart stores often keep hay in a dry, climate-controlled area, but bags can sit on shelves for a while. Always check the expiration date on the package. If the hay looks or smells off, skip it and try another location or brand.

Fun Tip for Baby Bunnies

Baby rabbits love to burrow and hide in fresh hay. You can stuff a handful of alfalfa hay into a rabbit hay rack attached to their pen, or simply pile it in a clean corner. It encourages natural foraging behavior and keeps them entertained for hours.

Is PetSmart’s Branded Hay Different From Store Brands?

PetSmart carries several hay brands, including their own store brand (EveryYay) and premium brands like Oxbow and Kaytee. The store brand is usually cheaper, but it is still safe for baby rabbits as long as it is fresh and correctly labeled as alfalfa. However, premium brands like Oxbow often have stricter quality control, meaning less dust and fewer stems. For a baby rabbit with a sensitive digestive system, spending a little extra on a trusted brand can be worth it. If you are on a tight budget, the EveryYay alfalfa hay is fine, but always inspect it first.

How to Store Hay From PetSmart to Keep It Safe

Once you bring the hay home, proper storage is key to keeping it safe for your baby rabbit. Hay can quickly go bad if it gets damp or warm. Follow these steps:

  • Transfer the hay to a breathable container like a paper bag or a cardboard box with holes. Do not use a plastic bag, as it traps moisture and encourages mold.
  • Store it in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight. A closet or a pantry works well.
  • Only take out a few days’ worth of hay at a time to keep the rest fresh.

If you notice any signs of spoilage after opening the bag, throw it away immediately. Moldy hay can cause serious respiratory issues in baby rabbits.

What If Your Baby Rabbit Refuses to Eat PetSmart Hay?

Sometimes a baby rabbit might turn up its nose at hay from PetSmart. This could mean the hay is not fresh, or your bunny simply prefers a different texture or brand. Try mixing a small amount of a new hay with their old hay to transition them slowly. You can also offer hay in different ways, like placing it inside a rabbit tunnel or a cardboard tube to make it more fun. If your baby rabbit still refuses to eat hay after 24 hours, contact your vet, as lack of hay can lead to serious digestive problems like GI stasis.

“Hay is the foundation of a rabbit’s health. If they stop eating it, something is wrong, and you need to act fast.”

Are There Any Risks With PetSmart Hay for Baby Rabbits?

The main risks are the same with any store-bought hay: dust, mold, and age. Baby rabbits have very sensitive respiratory systems, so dusty hay can cause sneezing or eye irritation. If you notice your baby rabbit sneezing after eating hay, try shaking the hay outside before giving it to them to remove excess dust. Also, watch for any signs of diarrhea or bloating, which could indicate a reaction to the hay. If symptoms persist, stop using that batch and consult your vet. For extra peace of mind, you can also order hay directly from farms that specialize in small animal feed, but PetSmart hay is a perfectly safe and convenient option for most owners.

Other Essentials for Your Baby Rabbit’s Setup

While hay is the star of the show, your baby rabbit will need a few other things to thrive. A safe, cozy space is important, and a rabbit hideout gives them a place to feel secure. You will also want to provide safe rabbit chew toys to help with teething and keep their teeth healthy. As they grow, a rabbit exercise pen will give them plenty of room to hop and play. Always pair their hay with fresh water and a small amount of age-appropriate pellets. And remember, every rabbit is different, so watch your baby bunny’s behavior and adjust their diet as needed with guidance from your vet.