🏆 Complete Buyer's Guide · Dog Care Products

Looking for a Medium Dog Subscription Box? 5 Best 2026 Picks

Bullymake Box wins for heavy chewers with tough toys and a replacement guarantee, while BarkBox Super Chewer and PupBox offer themed and training-focused alternatives.

PE
ProPawPicks Editorial Team
ProPawPicks Reviewer
Updated

Some links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are based on product research, label data and suitability, not on commissions.

Bullymake Box ★ Top Pick: Bullymake Box Check Price on Amazon →
5 to 7
Items per box (typical)
$20 to $50
Monthly cost range
2 to 3
Average number of toys per box
30 to 60
Days between shipments
⚡ Key takeaways
  • Best Overall: Bullymake Box. Bullymake Box is designed specifically for power chewers, offering tough nylon and rubber.
  • Best for Aggressive Chewers: BarkBox Super Chewer. BarkBox Super Chewer delivers heavy-duty rubber toys and tough nylon chews in a themed box.
  • Best Puzzle Toy: PupBox. PupBox focuses on training and enrichment, with age-appropriate puzzle toys and training a.
  • Best Dental Chew: The Farmers Dog. The Farmers Dog is a fresh food subscription that offers dental chews as an add-on.
  • Best Budget: Chewy Goody Box. Chewy's Goody Box is a one-time purchase or subscription that includes a variety of toys,.
At a Glance

Quick Comparison

ProductBest For
Bullymake Box Best Overall Check price →
BarkBox Super Chewer Best for Aggressive Chewers Check price →
PupBox Best Puzzle Toy Check price →
The Farmers Dog Best Dental Chew Check price →
Chewy Goody Box Best Budget Check price →

Quick answer

The Bullymake Box is our top pick for medium dogs because it offers durable nylon and rubber toys designed for power chewers, plus treats and a chew. For dogs that prefer softer play, the BarkBox Super Chewer delivers tough toys with a fun theme. If your dog loves puzzles, consider the PupBox, which includes training aids and age-appropriate toys.

What to consider for Dog Subscription Box For Medium Dogs

Medium dogs (roughly 25 to 50 pounds) have a wide range of energy levels and chew strengths. A box that works for a gentle Lab may not suit a determined Pit Bull. Look for boxes that offer toy toughness ratings, allow customization of treat preferences, and include items sized for medium jaws. Also consider the frequency of delivery and whether you can skip or cancel easily.

What to look for in a toy or chew (chew toy, puzzle, lick mat or dental chew)

When choosing items for a medium dog, size matters: toys should be too large to swallow but easy to carry. Durability must match your dog’s chewing style; for heavy chewers, look for rubber or nylon toys with a warranty. All materials should be non-toxic (BPA-free, phthalate-free). For dental chews, a VOHC seal indicates effectiveness. Puzzle toys should offer adjustable difficulty to keep your dog engaged without frustration.

How we chose these picks

  • Evaluated toy durability and safety based on manufacturer specifications and customer reviews.
  • Considered variety of items per box, including toys, treats, and chews.
  • Checked for customization options (toy toughness, treat preferences, size).
  • Assessed value for money relative to the number and quality of items.
  • Reviewed cancellation and shipping policies for flexibility.
  • Ensured all products are suitable for medium dogs (25 to 50 pounds).
  • Never ranked a product higher just because it pays a commission.

What to avoid

  • Toys small enough to be swallowed or lodged in the throat.
  • Hard chews like antlers or bones that can crack teeth.
  • Toys that shed pieces or have squeakers that can be removed and ingested.
  • Leaving a heavy chewer unsupervised with any new toy until you know its durability.

For more guidance, visit our dog guides, dog food, and dog health sections.

Why this matters

The Bullymake Box stands out for heavy chewers with its tough toys and replacement guarantee, while BarkBox Super Chewer offers themed variety. For mental stimulation, PupBox provides training-focused puzzles.

The Options

Types Explained

Toy-Focused Boxes

These boxes emphasize durable toys, often with a mix of rubber, nylon, and plush options. They are ideal for dogs that love to chew and play.

Best for: Active dogs that go through toys quickly and need constant rotation.

Treat and Chew Boxes

These boxes prioritize high-quality treats and dental chews, with fewer toys. They are great for training or dogs with specific dietary needs.

Best for: Dogs that are more food-motivated or have sensitive stomachs.

Enrichment Boxes

These boxes include puzzle toys, snuffle mats, and training tools to stimulate your dog's mind. They are perfect for intelligent breeds that need mental challenges.

Best for: Boredom-prone dogs or those that need to burn mental energy.

Customizable Boxes

These boxes allow you to tailor the contents based on your dog's size, chew strength, and preferences. They offer the most flexibility.

Best for: Owners who want a personalized experience and have specific requirements.
The Rankings

Top 5 Picks

#1
Bullymake Box
Best Overall

Bullymake Box

View on Amazon

Bullymake Box is designed specifically for power chewers, offering tough nylon and rubber toys that withstand aggressive chewing. Each box includes two toys, two treats, and a chew. The toys are made in the USA and come with a replacement guarantee if destroyed within 30 days. However, the treats may not suit dogs with allergies, and the box is pricier than some alternatives.

Check Price on Amazon →
#2
BarkBox Super Chewer
Best for Aggressive Chewers

BarkBox Super Chewer

View on Amazon

BarkBox Super Chewer delivers heavy-duty rubber toys and tough nylon chews in a themed box. The toys are designed to be nearly indestructible for strong chewers, and each box includes two toys, two bags of treats, and a chew. A downside is that the toys can be heavy for smaller medium dogs, and the subscription auto-renews unless canceled.

Check Price on Amazon →
#3
PupBox
Best Puzzle Toy

PupBox

View on Amazon

PupBox focuses on training and enrichment, with age-appropriate puzzle toys and training aids. Each box includes a puzzle toy, treats, and a training guide. It's ideal for medium dogs that need mental stimulation. However, the toys may not be durable enough for heavy chewers, and the box is more expensive per month than basic treat boxes.

Check Price on Amazon →
#4
The Farmers Dog
Best Dental Chew

The Farmers Dog

View on Amazon

The Farmers Dog is a fresh food subscription that offers dental chews as an add-on. The chews are VOHC-accepted and help reduce plaque and tartar. They are made from simple, natural ingredients. The main limitation is that you must also subscribe to the food, and the chews alone are not available as a standalone box.

Check Price on Amazon →
#5
Chewy Goody Box
Best Budget

Chewy Goody Box

View on Amazon

Chewy's Goody Box is a one-time purchase or subscription that includes a variety of toys, treats, and chews at a low price. It offers good value for medium dogs that are not extreme chewers. The downside is that the toys are not as durable as premium brands, and the contents vary by box, so you may not always get what you expect.

Check Price on Amazon →
Before You Buy

Key Buying Factors

01

Chew Strength Compatibility

Match the box's toy toughness to your dog's chewing style. Some boxes offer a 'power chewer' upgrade, while others are better for gentle mouths.

02

Customization Options

Look for boxes that let you choose toy toughness, treat flavors, or size. Customization ensures your dog enjoys every item and reduces waste.

03

Ingredient Quality

Check that treats and chews are made from natural, high-quality ingredients without artificial preservatives. This is especially important for dogs with allergies.

04

Subscription Flexibility

Consider whether you can skip, pause, or cancel easily. Some boxes require a commitment, while others are month-to-month.

05

Value for Money

Compare the number and quality of items to the price. A more expensive box may offer better durability or premium treats, making it worth the cost.

Living With It

Care, Cost and Maintenance

Rotate Toys Regularly

To keep your dog interested, rotate toys every few days. This prevents boredom and extends the life of each toy. Store unused toys out of reach.

Inspect Toys for Damage

Check toys regularly for signs of wear, such as cracks, loose parts, or torn fabric. Discard any damaged toys immediately to prevent ingestion.

Clean Toys Properly

Wash rubber and nylon toys with warm soapy water or in the dishwasher (top rack). Plush toys can be machine washed if they have no squeakers. Dry thoroughly to prevent mold.

Pro tip

Before committing to a subscription, try a one-time box or a short-term plan to see if the toys and treats match your dog's preferences and durability needs.

Frequently asked questions

Are subscription boxes safe for heavy chewers?
Many subscription boxes offer heavy-duty options specifically for aggressive chewers, such as Bullymake Box and BarkBox Super Chewer. These use tough rubber or nylon that resist punctures and tears. However, no toy is indestructible. Always supervise your dog with new toys and inspect them regularly for damage. If your dog is an extreme chewer, consider a box with a replacement guarantee.
How do I choose the right size toy for my medium dog?
Toys should be large enough that they cannot be swallowed whole but small enough for your dog to carry comfortably. For medium dogs (25 to 50 pounds), look for toys labeled 'medium' or with dimensions around 4 to 6 inches in length. Avoid toys with small parts that could be chewed off. When in doubt, size up for safety.
Should I supervise my dog with subscription box toys?
Yes, always supervise your dog when introducing a new toy, especially if it contains squeakers, stuffing, or small parts. Some dogs may try to destroy and ingest pieces, leading to choking or intestinal blockages. Once you are confident the toy is durable and your dog plays appropriately, you can allow unsupervised play, but periodic checks are still recommended.
What are the benefits of dental chews in subscription boxes?
Dental chews help reduce plaque and tartar buildup, promoting better oral health. Many subscription boxes include VOHC-accepted dental chews that are safe and effective. Regular use can freshen breath and prevent gum disease. However, dental chews should not replace regular brushing or professional cleanings. Always choose a size appropriate for your dog's weight.
Can puzzle toys in subscription boxes help with boredom?
Yes, puzzle toys engage a dog's mind and can alleviate boredom, which often leads to destructive behavior. They encourage problem-solving and can be filled with treats for added motivation. For medium dogs, look for puzzles with adjustable difficulty to keep them challenged. Rotating puzzles helps maintain interest.
What is the difference between digestible and non-digestible chews?
Digestible chews, like rawhide alternatives (e.g., bully sticks, collagen sticks), can be broken down in the stomach, reducing the risk of blockages. Non-digestible chews, such as nylon bones or rubber toys, are not meant to be eaten and should be discarded if pieces break off. For heavy chewers, non-digestible options are often more durable, but supervision is critical.
How do I clean toys from a subscription box?
Rubber and nylon toys can be washed with warm water and mild soap or placed on the top rack of a dishwasher. Plush toys with squeakers should be spot cleaned or machine washed on a gentle cycle if the manufacturer allows. Always air dry toys to prevent mold. For puzzle toys, disassemble if possible and clean all parts.
Are there any safety concerns with subscription box toys?
The main safety concerns are choking hazards from small parts, ingestion of stuffing or squeakers, and dental damage from overly hard chews. Always choose toys appropriate for your dog's size and chew strength. Avoid toys with loose strings or ribbons. If a toy becomes damaged, replace it immediately. Consult your vet if you have concerns about specific materials.
Can I cancel a subscription box if my dog doesn't like it?
Most subscription boxes allow you to cancel or skip a month, but policies vary. Many require cancellation before the next billing cycle, typically a few days before shipment. Some offer a satisfaction guarantee or refund for the first box. Always read the terms before subscribing. For flexibility, choose a box with no long-term commitment.
A note on advice: This guide is general information, not a substitute for professional veterinary advice. Talk to your vet before changing your pet's diet or care routine, especially if your pet has allergies, kidney disease, pancreatitis, obesity, heart disease or any other medical condition.
Transparency

How we made this guide

How we chose. We compared the options on the factors that matter most for Dog Care Products, using manufacturer specifications, aggregated verified owner reviews and editorial comparison. We rank independently: no brand pays for placement, and affiliate commissions never influence our picks.

How it was written. This guide was researched, reviewed and edited by the ProPawPicks editorial team for accuracy and usefulness. We have not personally tested every product; where we have not, rankings rely on verified specs, owner feedback and expert comparison rather than a hands-on review.

Affiliate disclosure. ProPawPicks is reader-supported. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure.

Keep Reading

More Dog Care Products guides

Picking Invisible Dog Fence for AllergiesView picks →Invisible Dog Fence for Large Dogs: 5 Best Picks (2026)View picks →2026 Puppy Fence Guide: 5 Top Invisible Dog Fences ReviewedView picks →Invisible Dog Fence under 50 That Hold UpView picks →Iris Puppy Playpens: 4 Best Reviewed (2026)View picks →Expert Pick: iRobot Roomba 692 for Dog Hair (2026)View picks →

Sources and further reading

Some links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are based on product research, label data and suitability, not on commissions.